9 Factors for Selecting Oil Seals

We just discovered that one of the seals on our pumping system is leaking. Do you have any ideas as to what could have caused this, and can you offer some advice for selecting a good seal?

The main causes of external lubricant leakage from pumping systems, hydraulic machines, gearcases and sumps are the wrong selection, improper application, poor installation and inadequate maintenance practices that are applied to sealing systems.

These problems can be overcome through a better understanding of the types of sealing materials available, redefined selection procedures and the consistent application of sound replacement and maintenance practices.

A number of variables must be considered when selecting oil seals. There are nine factors that designers and maintenance engineers must evaluate when oil seals are specified:

Shaft Speed

The maximum allowable shaft speed is a function of the shaft finish, runout, housing bore and shaft concentricity, type of fluid being sealed and the type of oil seal material.

Temperature

The temperature range of the mechanism in which the seal is installed must not exceed the temperature range of the seal elastomer.

Pressure

Most conventional oil seals are designed only to withstand very low-pressure applications (about 8 psi or less). If additional internal pressure is present or anticipated, pressure relief is necessary.

Shaft Hardness

Longer seal life can be expected with shafts having a Rockwell (RC) hardness of 30 or more. When exposed to abrasive contamination, the hardness should be increased to RC 60.

Shaft Surface Finish

Most effective sealing is obtained with optimum shaft surface finishes. The sealing efficiency is affected by the direction of the finish tool marks and the spiral lead. Best sealing results are obtained with polished or ground shafts with concentric (no spiral lead) finish marks. If you must use shafts with spiral finish leads, they should lead toward the fluid when the shaft rotates.

Concentricity

When the bore and shaft centers are misaligned, seal life will be shortened because the wear will be concentrated on one side of the sealing lip.

Shaft and Bore Tolerances

The best seal performance is achieved when close shaft and bore tolerances are present. Other factors include shaft eccentricity, end play and vibration.

Runout

Runout must be kept to a minimum. Movement of the center of rotation is usually caused by bearing wobble or shaft whip. When coupled with misalignment, this problem is compounded. Contrary to popular belief and common practice, the installation of flexible couplings cannot correct or compensate for misalignment.

Lubricant

Seals perform much better and longer when they are continuously lubricated with an oil that has the correct viscosity for the application and that is compatible with the seal lip elastomer material. The consideration of seal incompatibility, particularly with certain additives and some synthetic lubricants, should not be ignored, but unfortunately very often is.

In Part 1, we explained the structure, functions, and types of oil seals.

Oil Seals (Part 1): The structure, functions, and types of oil seals

Oil seals come in various shapes to fit the machines and substances to be sealed.
For this reason, when designing a machine, it is important to select the oil seal that is right for that machine.

That's where this column comes in.
We will explain the key points for selecting the oil seal that is right for your machine.

1. Criteria for selecting oil seals

Oil seals come in a wide range of types, and they also have various sizes.
When selecting the right oil seal for your machine from among these many varied types of oil seals, the following two criteria are very important.

• Criterion 1: It should be appropriate for the machine's usage environment and the operating condition that is being demanded of the oil seal
• Criterion 2: It should be easy to acquire replacement oil seals and it should facilitate maintenance/inspection of the machine

If these criteria are met, damage of the machine can be reduced, the time needed to replace the oil seals when performing repairs can be shortened, and the machine can be used for a longer period of time.

In this way, selecting the appropriate oil seal will lead to machine design that is economically superior!

2. How to select the right oil seal

In general, oil seals should be selected in the order of priority indicated in Table 1.

However, when you actually select the oil seal to use, the most important factors are past success history and points of improvement, so it is not necessary to follow this order to the letter.

Table 1: The order of priority for selecting oil seals

No. Examination item 1 Seal type 2 Rubber material 3 Metal case and spring material

1) Seal type

Select your oil seal type according to Table 2.

Table 2: How to select the seal type

No. Examination item Flowcharts 1 O.D. (outside diameter) wall material Figure 1 2 Necessity of spring Figure 2 3 Lip type Figure 3

Figure 1: O.D. (outside diameter) wall material

Figure 2: Necessity of spring

Figure 3: Lip type

 

＜Seal selection example＞
Based on the above flowcharts, the oil seal type that meets the requirements shown in Table 3 would be the type code MHSA or HMSA shown in Table 4.

Table 3: Requirements

No. Requirements 1 Housing Made of steel, one solid design, housing bore surface roughness 1.8 μmRa 2 Substance to be sealed Grease 3 Pressure Atmospheric 4

Shaft surface speed

(peripheral speed)

6 m/s 5 Air-side condition Dusty

Table 4: Type of selected seal

Type 1 Type 2 O.D. wall material Rubber O.D. wall Metal O.D. wall Necessity of spring Spring required Spring required Lip shape Minor lip required Minor lip required
Type (type code)

For a more detailed discussion of seal types and type codes, please see the following:

2) Rubber material

The rubber material used in the oil seal should be selected based on the operational temperature and substance to be sealed.
Table 5 lists the major rubber materials along with their operational temperature ranges.
Note that it is necessary to check the compatibility with fluids.
＜N.B.＞
Extreme pressure additives are compounds added to the lubricant. They are activated by heat and chemically react against rubber, which deteriorates rubber properties. For this reason, it is necessary to check for compatibility with rubber materials.

Table 5: Major rubber materials and their operational temperature ranges

Rubber material
(ASTM*1 code) Grade Features Operational temperature range (°C) Compatibility with fluids

Nitrile rubber (NBR)

Standard type

Well-balanced in terms of resistance to abrasion and high and low temperatures

-30～

100

Necessary to check compatibility with fluids
(See *2)

Fluids
• Fuel oil
• Lubricating oil
• Hydraulic fluid
• Grease
• Chemicals
• Water

High- and low-temperature-resistant type Highly resistant to both high and low temperatures -40～

110

Hydrogenated nitrile rubber (HNBR)

Standard type

Compared with nitrile rubber, superior in resistance to heat and abrasion

-30～

140

Acrylic rubber (ACM)

Standard type High oil resistance and good abrasion resistance -20～

150

High- and low-temperature-resistant type Improved low temperature resistance and same level of heat resistance as the standard type -30～

150

Silicone rubber (VMQ)

Standard type Wide operational temperature range and good abrasion resistance -50～

170

Fluoro rubber (FKM)

Standard type The most superior in resistance to heat, and good abrasion resistance -20～

180

Notes
*1 ASTM: American Society for Testing and Materials
*2 For more details on fluid compatibility, please see the following:

Rubber materials, operational temperature ranges and their compatibility with fluids

3) Metal case and spring material

The metal case and spring material used in the oil seal should be selected based on the substance to be sealed.
Table 6 shows how to select the metal case and spring materials.

Table 6: Selection of metal case and spring materials

Substance to be sealed Material Metal case Spring

Cold rolled carbon steel sheet
(JIS* SPCC)

Stainless steel sheet
(JIS* SUS304)

High carbon steel wire
(JIS* SWB)

Stainless steel wire
(JIS* SUS304) Oil ○ ― ○ ― Grease ○ ― ○ ― Water × ○ × ○ Seawater × × ○ Water vapor × ○ × ○ Chemicals × ○ × ○ Organic solvent ○ ○ ○ ○

Notes
* JIS: Japanese Industrial Standard
✓: Compatible
✗: Incompatible
―: Not applicable

 
3. Shaft and housing design

Oil seals can show good sealing performance in combination with properly designed shafts and housings.

1) Shaft design

Table 7 shows the shaft design checklist.

Table 7: Shaft design checklist

No. Examination item Major points to confirm Remarks 1 Material Use one of the carbon steels for machine structural use, low-alloy steel, or stainless steel. Soft materials (brass and so on) are not suitable. 2 Hardness Shaft hardness should be at least 30 HRC. In usage conditions where wear can occur easily because of dust or contaminated oil, hardness should be 50-60 HRC. 3 Shaft diameter tolerance This should be h8 (seals are designed to suit shafts with a tolerance of h8). 4 Shaft end chamfer "Provide a chamfer on the shaft end.
(This prevents failure during mounting.)" See Figure 4. 5 Surface roughness and finishing The shaft surface to be in contact with the lip should be finished to
0.1 to 0.32 μmRa and 0.8 to 2.5 μmRz
and the lead angle to no greater than 0.05°. (There is a risk that the lead marks will impede the sealing performance of the oil seal: see Figure 5.)

Nominal shaft diameter
d1, mm d1-d2, mm を超え 以下 ― 10 1.5 min. 10 20 2.0 min. 20 30 2.5 min.

Figure 4: Shaft end chamfer

a) Good finished surface
(no lead marks) b) Undesirable finished surface
(visible lead marks)

Figure 5: Shaft surface with and without lead marks

2) Housing design

Table 8 shows the housing design checklist.

Table 8: Housing design checklist

No. Examination item Major points to confirm Remarks Material Steel or cast iron is generally used as the housing material.
Aluminum alloys and resin (materials with a large difference between the linear expansion coefficients) demand sufficient consideration (as there is a risk of failure due to the increased clearance with the oil seal at high temperatures). 2 Bore diameter tolerance 1. If the nominal bore diameter is 400 mm or less:
H7 or H8
2. If the nominal bore diameter exceeds 400 mm:
H7 3 Bore inlet chamfer Provide an appropriate chamfer with rounded corners.
(This facilitates mounting.) See Figure 6. 4 Shoulder diameter
(if the housing bore has a shoulder) Set appropriate shoulder diameter. See Figure 7. 5 Bore surface roughness 1. For metal O.D. wall type:
0.4 to 1.6 μmRa,
1.6 to 6.3 μmRz
2. For rubber O.D. wall type:
1.6 to 3.2 μmRa,
6.3 to 12.5 μmRz
(Firmly affixes the oil seal and prevents leakage through the seal O.D.)

Nominal seal width
b, mm

B1 min.
mm L
mm Over Up to ― 10 b + 0.5 1.0 10 18 1.5 18 50 b + 0.8

Figure 6: Recommended housing bore chamfers (shouldered bore)

Nominal seal O.D.
D, mm

F

mm Over Up to ― 10 D - 4 10 18 D - 6 18 50 D - 8

Figure 7: Recommended housing shoulder diameters

3) Total eccentricity

When the total eccentricity is excessive, the sealing edge of the seal lip cannot accommodate shaft motions and leakage may occur.
Total eccentricity is the sum of shaft runout and the housing-bore eccentricity.
Total eccentricity, shaft runout and housing-bore eccentricity are generally expressed in TIR (Total Indicator Reading).

A) Shaft runout
As shown in Figure 8, shaft runout is defined as being twice the eccentricity between the shaft center and center of shaft-center rotation trajectory.

Figure 8: Shaft runout

B) Housing-bore eccentricity
As shown in Figure 9, housing-bore eccentricity is defined as being twice the eccentricity between the housing-bore center and shaft rotation center.

Figure 9: Housing-bore eccentricity

4) Allowable total eccentricity

The allowable total eccentricity is the maximum total eccentricity at which the sealing edge can accommodate shaft rotation and retain adequate sealing performance. The oil seal's allowable total eccentricity is affected by the design of the oil seal, the accuracy of the shaft, and the operating conditions.

For details on shaft and housing design, please see the following:
Examples of allowable total eccentricity for oil seals

4. Seal characteristics

Oil seal performance is affected by not only the type and material of the selected oil seal, but also a variety of other factors, such as operating conditions, total eccentricity, rotational speed, the substance to be sealed, and lubrication conditions.
Figure 9 shows items relating to oil seal characteristics.

Figure 9: Items relating to oil seal characteristics

No. Item Content Major factors 1 Sealing property Lip pumped volume
(the volume of oil, etc., pushed back at the lip contact area per unit of time) • Shape
(hydrodynamic ribs)
• Rotational speed
• Oil viscosity, etc. 2 Oil seal service life Wear on the rubber material
Loss of lip sealing function • Operational temperature
• Total eccentricity
• Rotational speed
• Substance to be sealed
• Lubrication conditions, etc. 3 Lip temperature Temperature rise due to sealing edge friction heat because of the shaft rotation • Rotational speed, etc. 4 Allowable peripheral speed When shaft rotation is extremely fast, the sealing performance deteriorates. • Total eccentricity
• Rubber material
• Seal type, etc. 5 Allowable internal pressure Internal pressure is a factor that may deteriorate seal performance. • Total eccentricity, etc. 6 Seal torque The seal torque is large. • Lip radial load
• Lubricating oil
• Rotational speed
• Shaft diameter, etc.

For a more detailed discussion of seal characteristics, please see the following:
Seal characteristics

5. Conclusion

When selecting the oil seal that is right for your machine, it is important that the oil seal be appropriate for the requirements of the usage environment and that it be easily acquired for replacement.
In this month's column, "How to select the right oil seal," we conveyed the following points:

1) Oil seal shape and material should be selected based on the housing, substance to be sealed, pressure, rotational speed, total eccentricity, and air-side conditions.
2) Oil seals can show good sealing performance in combination with properly designed shafts and housings.
3) Oil seal performance is affected by not only the type and material of the selected oil seal, but also a variety of other factors, such as operating conditions, total eccentricity, rotational speed, the substance to be sealed, and lubrication conditions. For this reason, diligent care is required in oil seal selection.

In order for the sealing property of the oil seal you selected to really shine, attention needs to be paid to how it is handled.
In the event of seal failure, it is necessary to take effective countermeasures.

We will cover these points in the next column, "Oil Seals (Part 3)".

If you have any technical questions regarding oil seals, or opinions/thoughts on these "Bearing Trivia" pages, please feel free to contact us using the following form:

Nitrile Butadiene Rubber (NBR, nitrile)

NBR, also known as nitrile rubber or nitrile, is the most popular material for an oil seal because of its good resistance to many oils and greases, such as mineral grease and hydraulic oil. Depending on their composition, synthetic oils and greases, such as those based on glycol, can damage NBR rubber materials. Depending on the amount of glycol, a PTFE lip seal may be the best choice. NBR is also unable to cope with contact with acids and solvents. The rubber is suitable for oil and grease at temperatures from -35 °C to 100 °C.

Most ERIKS oil seals, such as the types M, MST, R and RST, are made of NBR as standard.

Fluorine rubber (FKM, Viton™)

FKM or FPM, which is in well-known brand Viton™, can withstand higher liquid temperatures of up to 180 ˚C. FKM is highly resistant to strong acids and bases, as well as to synthetic oils and greases. Glycol-based oil and grease, however, can also damage FKM.

Because of the higher temperature resistance of FKM, this material is also chosen for applications where higher speeds play a role, which raise the temperature at the sealing lip considerably. Usually, using FKM will result in a longer life than using NBR. This compensates the higher price of FKM compared to NBR, as an FKM does not have to be replaced as frequently. The low temperature resistance of standard FKM is limited to -15 ˚C.

Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE, Teflon®)

PTFE, which is used in the well-known brand Teflon®, is less commonly used, but it is the preferred material for specific rotating seals in the chemical, food and pharmaceutical industries. This material is notable for having a very low frictional resistance and the best chemical resistance. It can also withstand a very wide range of temperatures in these types of seals; -80 ˚C to 200 ˚C. The shafts on which oil seals with PTFE lips are used require a harder and finer finish. Something like an axle sleeve can also be used to meet this requirement.

EPDM

EPDM oil seals are less common. They are used in solvent, hot water and steam applications, EPDM resists low temperatures down to -50 °C and UV radiation well. Some types of EPDM are also suitable for higher temperatures up to +150 °C. EPDM oil seals are usually available upon request.

VMQ (silicone)

VMQ, also known as silicone, is also used for oil seals, but this is less common because the mechanical strength of VMQ is low and this material has poor wear-resistance This makes it less suitable for dynamic applications, but it can withstand fairly low and high temperatures from -60 °C to 200 °C. Many types of VMQ are also suitable for contact with pharmaceutical and food products, so VMQ is an option worth considering. VMQ oil seals are usually available on request.